Megalithic art in Brittany

Megalithic art in Brittany

Elizabeth Shee Twohig has coined the term Megalithic art in her study of ‘The Megalithic Art of Western Europe’ [1]. Her original definition of Megalithic art focussed on paintings or carvings found on the structural elements, like the kerbstones, orthostats, or capstones of megalithic tombs, but recent investigations have included decorations on Stelae and Menhirs.

Shee Twohig [1] lists 39 sites in France, most are concentrated in Brittany. Other important sites with megalithic art can be found in Iberia, Britain, Ireland and Germany.

Shee Twohig [1] describes nine principle motifs of megalithic art found in Breton passage tombs.

Main motifs of Breton megalithic art (after Shee Twohig)
  1. Cupmark
  2. U motif
  3. Yoke
  4. Crook
  5. Cross
  6. Angle 7
  7. Axe-triangular blade
  8. Hafted axe
  9. Mané Retual type axe
  10. Buckler
  11. Wavy lines

Early Breton Passage art

Passage tombs were built in Brittany as early as 4675 BC. The Kercado tomb near Carnac is one of the oldest known. It has a clear layout: A long passage (6.5 m) leads to a rectangular chamber. In later monuments variations and additional features were added.

Engravings in the Mané Lud passage tomb

With the modification of the tombs the megalithic art underwent development too. In the oldest monuments simple symbols like axes, yokes and crooks are found. In the second half of the 5th millennium BC motifs became more developed (compare [2]).

Reutilization of Stelae

A number of motives appear on carved slabs that were used as stelae. Some seem to be still in place now as orthostats of tombs. Examples are the back stone of the Table des Marchants or Mane Lud in Locmariaquer.

Table des Marchands – Gavrinis Stele.

Others were re-used as capstones. Examples include the capstone of the Kercado tomb, Mane Rutual and again the Table des Marchants. The latter one was once part of 10 m tall stele that was broken, intentionally or not into pieces. The upper bit was found 4 km away, across a river in the Gavrinis tomb (now on an island). The carvings of this piece were placed upright and could not been seen in the tomb.

There is further proof of the re-use of decorated slabs. For example in Le Petit-Mont in Azon: The orthostat C2 of Cairn II seems to be a ‘modified’ stele. The ‘head’ of a buckler motif was removed and the stone is positioned upside down. Floorstones in Mane Lud and Petit-Mont were also identified as re-used stelae. It seems to be likely that other carved capstones and some orthostats were re-used stelae. Examples include amongst the already mentioned Ile Longue, Dissinac and Barnez.

Six motives can be found on the stelae: 1.The ‘buckler’ motif placed as the capstone of the chamber (Mané-Rutual) or the passage (Ile Longue, Barnenez, Petit-Mont II), or re-used as an orthostat (La Table des Marchands, Gavrinis), 2. The ‘axe plough’ (Kercado, Gavrinis, Mane Rutual), 3. hafted axe (La Table des Marchants), 4.Crook, 5. Horn motifs, 6. Zoomotives and Bovines.

A ‘axe plough’ motif was also found on the Grand Menhir in Locmariaquer. Further, sockets for an alignment of eighteen standing stones were found on the side of the Grand Menhir and it seems likely that the decorated stelae pre-date the tombs.

It is argued that many decorations on standing stones were destroyed by weathering. This seems to be supported by fact that carvings on standing stones can be found where these were protected from weathering. Examples are the Menhir de Kermaillard or the Giant of Kerzerho.

Further it is argued that many stones might have been painted. This is suggested because many menhirs have plain surfaces that might have been a preparation for paintings on this surface. Apparently no paintings survived in the climate of Brittany, but paintings are known from megalithic buildings on the Iberian Peninsula.

Angled passage tomb motifs

In 4th millennium elaborated figurines appeared. These can be found in the angled passage tombs of the Carnac area in Morbihan. Examples of angle passage tombs are Goërem, Luffang, Le Rocher and Les Pierres-Plats.

Figurines in the Pierres-Plats tomb
Figurine in the Pierres-Plats tomb.

The carvings in angle passage tombs are often interpreted as anthromorphic representations of a female goddess.

Later Neolithic

In Later Neolithic (around 3000 BC) allées-couvertes were build in parts of Brittany. Some of these show depictions of breasts in relief. In the same period also axes in relief (e.g in Gavrinis) were produced.

Allée couverte de Tressé

References

[1] E. Twohig, The megalithic art of western europe, Oxford New York: Clarendon press oxford university press, 1981.
[Bibtex]
@Book{Twohig1981,
author = {Twohig, Elizabeth},
publisher = {Clarendon Press Oxford University Press},
title = {The megalithic art of Western Europe},
year = {1981},
address = {Oxford New York},
isbn = {0-19-813193-3},
}
[2] A. Burl, Megalithic brittany : a guide to over 350 ancient sites and monuments, London: Thames and hudson, 1985.
[Bibtex]
@Book{Burl85,
author = {Burl, Aubrey},
publisher = {Thames and Hudson},
title = {Megalithic Brittany : a guide to over 350 ancient sites and monuments},
year = {1985},
address = {London},
isbn = {0-500-27460-6},
}